Autumn soup and bread on a neatly set table beside a colonial inn window, with burgundy chairs and warm plaster walls.

A Day of Eating at the Colts Neck Crossroads

At 11 a.m. on a Thursday in February 2016, Huddy's Inn opened its new location at the corner of Routes 537 and 34, and its 40-seat bar filled within an hour. The Two River Times called it the answer to "Colts Neck's most frequently asked question." The restaurant had taken five years to build inside part of the township's former Atlantic School.

The restaurant carries the name of Captain Joshua Huddy, who ran a tavern at the same intersection about 240 years earlier. His tavern is the one people now call the Colts Neck Inn. A short walk west on County Road 537, a deli works out of an 1849 mill. A single crossroads has three places to eat in three buildings that each began as something else, and you can go from first coffee to a late bar menu without moving the car more than a few hundred yards.

7 a.m.: the mill that became a deli

The Colts Neck General Store & Deli at 171 County Road 537 is in the second-oldest of the three buildings. Patch's October 2024 profile for its 175th anniversary says the Matthews family founded it in 1849 and built it as a mill. Parts of that first structure are still visible in the rafters.

Owner Mary Pahira told Patch the building has been a butcher shop, a hardware store and a liquor shop. She said it has been a deli for the last 35 to 40 years. She also said a liquor store around the corner got its license from the General Store years ago.

The sandwich to order is the pork roll, egg and cheese. Pahira first heard about the store in 2008, when her co-workers at Delicious Orchards kept taking turns driving over for that sandwich. NJ101.5 later voted the store one of the state's best places to get one. She started working there in March 2009 and bought the store in March 2017. During the pandemic shutdown she replaced the drop ceiling and redid the lighting, flooring and register displays.

When Patch visited in 2024, the store was open seven days a week for breakfast and lunch. It also sold custom gift baskets, candles and baked goods. "At 7 a.m. I open the doors, the coffee's made, and I've got people already waiting to just get in and sit down and take up a whole table," Pahira said. Before you go, check the store's Facebook page for current hours.

The tavern Huddy ran

To see why a 2016 restaurant is named for an 18th-century militia captain, start at the inn. According to the Monmouth County Archives, Catherine Hart inherited a Colts Neck tavern from her late husband, Levi Hart. She married Joshua Huddy on October 27, 1778, and he ran the tavern when he wasn't on militia duty. The Archives place it near today's Colts Neck Inn at Routes 34 and 537.

In September 1780, Loyalist raiders besieged Huddy's Colts Neck house. With help from Lucretia Emmons, Huddy loaded and fired muskets from different parts of the house. The attackers set the house on fire before he surrendered. Patriots then fired on the Loyalists' boat, and Huddy escaped by swimming to shore. He was captured at Toms River in March 1782. On April 12, 1782, Loyalists hanged him at the Navesink Highlands, according to the Monmouth County Historical Association. Edible Jersey reports that Catherine Hart kept running the business until 1817.

3 p.m.: the 1717 inn with a 2025 dining room

The Colts Neck Inn Steakhouse at 191 County Road 537 dates itself to 1717. General manager Fay Gianaris told Edible Jersey it is one of New Jersey's oldest inns and the sixth-oldest in the country. She said it was a stagecoach stop halfway between Trenton and New York City, with six sleeping rooms upstairs and a restaurant on the main floor. One wall of the original building still stands.

The current family's history at the inn starts in 1973. The Asbury Park Press reported that the late George Mavrookas left Greece in 1955 and took a job at the United Nations, where he learned English from a co-worker over lunch breaks. He then ran a luncheonette in North Jersey before buying the Colts Neck Inn in 1973. The family later built the Colts Neck Inn Hotel next door. Edible Jersey says the inn was known for its smorgasbord lunch buffet in the 1970s and for a Friday night seafood buffet in the 1980s.

If you haven't been inside in a couple of years, the oldest dining room in town will look like the newest. In March 2025, Best of NJ described a four-month renovation that covered the exterior, dining room, bar, banquet rooms, booths, plates and flatware. Gray, black and gold replaced the dark mahogany and the burgundy-and-green décor. The steaks stayed. Sushi, a raw bar, chicken, salmon and halibut were added. The inn's current menu lists oysters, clams, shrimp cocktail and tuna tartare from the raw bar, plus maki and specialty rolls. Edible Jersey adds double-cut pork chops and rack of lamb to the hand-cut steaks.

The inn's website lists service Tuesday through Sunday starting at 3 p.m. and takes reservations online. Monday is the one night the crossroads has no steakhouse.

Late: the school that became Huddy's

Huddy's Inn moved to the crossroads from somewhere close by. Before February 2016, it spent more than 25 years in the Colts Neck Shopping Center on Route 34. The old location closed on Super Bowl Sunday, and the new one was serving capacity crowds by Valentine's weekend.

The Two River Times reported that the five-year buildout ran into a wastewater approval process complicated by a sensitive stream nearby. Contractors also left for months after Superstorm Sandy. The site is next to Pebble Creek Golf Course, and crews took down part of the former school and split the building in two, with offices in front and the restaurant behind. The new Huddy's was more than three times the size of the old space, with three windowed dining rooms, a large bar, outdoor space and views of the golf course from every window.

The walls hold the town's history. When Huddy's opened at the corner, one wall had historic photos from Colts Neck's Laird's Distillery. A rear dining room had a large painting that hung for half a century in a Route 34 business that has since closed. A custom display held a set of collector Colts Neck plates showing local historic sites. The American menu covered burgers, salads, steaks, seafood and pastas. Monmouth Guide describes Huddy's as a tavern-style spot with classic American food and a late-night bar menu. On opening day, a resident at the bar told the Two River Times the local Lions Club would meet there.

Down Route 34, where Huddy's came from

Most of the other places to eat in town are on Route 34 south of the crossroads, along the stretch Huddy's left in 2016.

The plaza at 340 Route 34, which Monmouth Guide calls the Orchards Plaza, has several of them. Colts Neck Eatery serves breakfast, brunch and lunch, with omelets, pancakes and waffles to eat in or take out. The Bagel Store and Rook Coffee share that address, and so does La Candela Gallega, which is listed under Spanish and Mexican food. Jersey Freeze lists its Colts Neck location there as "Since 2025" and serves only ice cream at this one.

Delicious Orchards is next door at 320 Route 34, and its scratch bakery is known for seasonal fruit pies and apple cider donuts. Via Sposito at 323 Route 34 makes fresh mozzarella and pasta in-house and also serves coal-fired pizza and USDA Prime dry-aged steaks at a full bar. That gives Route 34 a dry-aged steak of its own, a few minutes south of the inn. Colts Neck Pub at 270 Route 34 is a neighborhood sports bar known for calamari, loaded fries and buffalo chicken sliders. Farther south, Prima Pizza at 943 Route 34 is a family-run shop known for its Grandma pie. It posts hours of 11 a.m. to 7:45 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 11 a.m. to 8:45 p.m. Friday.

For a drink in the afternoon, Source Farmhouse Brewery at 300 Route 34 and Colts Neck Stillhouse at 304 Route 34 are side by side on the same strip. We wrote about both, along with the farm stops around them, in the three-mile stretch that makes a Colts Neck summer.

The Thanksgiving-week version

Delicious Orchards' pie page guarantees apple, pecan and pumpkin pies during Thanksgiving week. Any other flavor depends on what the bakery has that day. Its 2026 Thanksgiving catering menu covers November 21 through 25 and needs 72 hours' notice. It includes turkey breast, stuffing, mashed potatoes and vegetables. Via Sposito advertises a $395 Thanksgiving package for 8 to 10 people, plus a Thanksgiving dinner at the restaurant. Call to confirm dates.

For guests staying through the long weekend, breakfast at the General Store at 171 County Road 537 and dinner at the Colts Neck Inn at 191 County Road 537 are on the same road.

If you own a home near this crossroads and want to know where its value stands this season, Doreen DeMarco can start with a free home valuation. More Colts Neck stories are on our Colts Neck page.

Work With Doreen

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram